When I Work now sells two plans: $2.50 per user a month for a single location and $5 for multiple locations, with the time clock included in both. Payroll itself comes from a partner, and there is no single exception inbox for managers. If you’re looking for When I Work alternatives, here are five real options for 2026, including when each competitor actually beats ClockOut for your specific situation.
Why people switch from When I Work
Three complaints come up most often when teams look for When I Work alternatives:
- A second location doubles the price. One location (or schedule) is $2.50 per user a month. As soon as you run multiple locations or schedules, every user moves to the $5 plan, so a 25-person team goes from $62.50 to $125 a month.
- Payroll is a separate product. Every plan has payroll integrations, but payroll itself comes from a partner (the pricing page promotes Rippling), adding another line item for teams that want end-to-end hours → payroll workflow.
- No exception inbox. Late arrivals, no-shows, missed breaks, and unapproved overtime surface in scattered views (the schedule, the time-approval queue, the alerts feed) rather than a single manager-facing queue. For a busy floor manager, that means more tab-switching and more misses.
None of these are dealbreakers for every team. But if any of them ring familiar, one of the five options below is likely a cleaner fit.
1. ClockOut: best for time-clock-first teams
ClockOut is built around the punch, not the schedule. Every paid plan bundles GPS clock-in/out, geofencing, kiosk mode, and the exception inbox together, there’s no separate attendance module to add on.
- Free plan: up to 2 people, including you, forever, no credit card required.
- Starter ($19 a month for up to 5 people, then $3 per extra person): GPS + geofencing, kiosk mode (4 to 6 digit PIN on a tablet an admin sets up once), exception inbox, open shifts & swaps, PTO & availability, push/email alerts, timesheet approvals, recurring schedules, overtime alerts & break compliance.
- Pro ($39 a month for up to 5, then $6 each): everything in Starter plus multi-location, payroll runs (lock & export), ADP / Gusto / QuickBooks exports, compliance rules engine, scoped roles & departments, PDF payroll reports, monthly attendance view, API access.
- Offline mode: clock-ins captured when connectivity drops, synced when it returns. Useful for walk-in coolers, basements, and remote sites.
- Setup time: ~60 seconds to sign up and add your first employee.
The caveat: ClockOut is newer than When I Work and Homebase. Integrations and advanced reporting are growing, but if you need a decade-long audit trail or a native POS integration, check the integrations page first.
For more detail, see ClockOut vs When I Work: full comparison.
2. Homebase: best for restaurants and retail
Homebase is a mature platform with scheduling, time tracking, hiring, and HR tools aimed squarely at restaurants and single-location retail. It has GPS + geofencing, kiosk mode, and payroll exports. For a restaurant owner who wants everything (hiring, onboarding, scheduling, time clock) under one roof, Homebase is a natural fit.
- Free Basic plan for 1 location and up to 10 employees.
- Paid plans are priced per location, not per employee: Essentials $30, Plus $70, and All-in-One $120 a month ($24, $56, and $96 billed annually).
- Exception inbox: not available.
- Compliance rules engine: available on higher tiers.
- Payroll exports to ADP, Gusto, and QuickBooks: yes.
Where Homebase loses to ClockOut: no exception inbox. Where it wins: a flat per-location price that gets cheaper per head as you grow (25 people on Essentials: $30 a month, against $79 on ClockOut Starter), and deeper hiring and HR features if you’re running a restaurant and want one platform for the whole employee lifecycle.
For a deeper look, see the ClockOut vs Homebase comparison.
3. Deputy: best for hospitality and shift compliance
Deputy is a solid scheduling-and-time-clock app popular in hospitality, aged care, and retail chains. It has GPS + geofencing, kiosk mode, and open shifts. The UI is polished and the scheduling engine handles complex rotations well.
- No free plan: Lite is $5.50 per user monthly ($5 annual), with a $30 monthly minimum.
- GPS + geofencing: yes.
- Kiosk mode: yes.
- Open shifts: yes.
- Payroll integrations: every plan; Deputy Payroll is an add-on ($8 per user plus a $49 monthly base fee).
- Compliance: Labor Law Compliance on Lite, Advanced Labor Law Compliance on Core.
- Exception inbox: not available.
Deputy’s sweet spot is multi-location hospitality with complex rosters. It’s less compelling for small teams that primarily need a reliable GPS time clock and don’t need the enterprise scheduling features. See the ClockOut vs Deputy breakdown for a line-by-line comparison.
4. 7shifts: best for restaurants only
7shifts is purpose-built for the restaurant industry and is excellent at what it does. Scheduling, time tracking, tip pooling, and payroll support are all restaurant-native. If you’re running a full-service or QSR restaurant and everyone on your team is front-of-house or back-of-house, 7shifts deserves a look.
- Priced per location: Essentials is $44.99 a month ($39.99 annual) for up to 30 employees, and the free Comp plan covers one location with up to 15 employees (no time clock).
- Time tracking from Essentials; tip management ($49.99 per location a month) and payroll ($39.99 per location plus $6 per employee paid) are add-ons.
- Strong restaurant-specific reporting (labor vs. sales).
The limitation: 7shifts is a restaurant tool. If you’re running a clinic, construction crew, retail store, or any non-restaurant shift operation, you’ll find features you don’t need and miss ones you do. Pick it if your whole team works in a kitchen or on a floor, look elsewhere otherwise.
5. Connecteam: best for field and deskless teams
Connecteam is designed for deskless, distributed workforces: think construction, cleaning services, home health aides, and delivery teams. Beyond scheduling and time tracking, it includes in-app chat, task management, checklists, forms, and training, a wider operations toolkit than most time clocks offer.
- Operations Basic runs $35 a month ($29 billed yearly) for the first 30 users, then $1 per extra user, making it cheap per-head at scale; the free Small Business plan covers up to 10 users.
- GPS time tracking: yes (Basic). Geofencing: Advanced, $59 a month ($49 yearly).
- Checklists, forms, and training alongside chat and tasks: strong differentiators.
- Exception inbox: not available.
Connecteam is overkill if you just need a time clock and scheduler. It shines when your team is distributed, rarely at a desk, and needs a communication layer alongside time tracking. See ClockOut vs Connecteam for a feature-by-feature breakdown.
Feature comparison
| ClockOut | When I Work | Homebase | Deputy | |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Free plan | Up to 2 people, including you, forever | 14-day trial | Basic: 1 location, up to 10 employees | None |
| Entry price (w/ time clock) | $19/mo for up to 5, then $3 per person | $2.50/user/mo one location, $5 multiple | $24-30 per location per month | $5.50/user/mo ($5 annual) |
| Exception inbox | ✓ | ✗ | ✗ | ✗ |
| GPS + geofencing | ✓ | ✓ | ✓ | ✓ |
| Kiosk mode | ✓ | ✓ | ✓ | ✓ |
| Compliance rules engine | ✓ | Partial | ✓ | Lite (Advanced on Core) |
| Payroll exports (ADP/Gusto/QB) | ✓ | ✓ | ✓ | Integrations on all plans |
| Setup time | ~60 sec | 1-2 days | ~30 min | ~20 min |
Competitor prices are from each vendor’s pricing page, checked October 15, 2026, and change often, so verify on each vendor’s site. When I Work includes the time clock in every plan; the $5 rate applies once you run multiple locations or schedules.
How to switch without losing data
Moving from When I Work to any of these alternatives is straightforward, but a few steps protect you:
- Export timesheets first. From When I Work, export your timesheet data as CSV before canceling. Keep a copy for at least 3 years for wage-and-hour compliance.
- Export your employee roster. When I Work lets you export a CSV of employee names, roles, and contact info. Most alternatives accept a CSV import to speed up setup.
- Run both apps in parallel for one pay period. Import employees into the new tool, run a week of punches alongside When I Work, and compare the totals before you cut over. One pay-period overlap costs almost nothing and catches configuration issues before they hit payroll.
- Notify employees in advance. A short message, “We’re switching to [new app] on [date], download it and use your PIN to clock in”, cuts confusion on day one.
- Check your geofence radii. Re-enter your location geofences in the new app, and consider running in “flag” mode (rather than “block”) for the first week so edge cases don’t prevent legitimate clock-ins while your team adjusts.
For a broader guide to free options while you evaluate, see the best free time clock apps for small businesses.