← All posts
Comparisons

ClockOut vs When I Work: Which Time Clock Fits a Small Team?

When I Work has been a small-business scheduling staple for years. It works. It charges per user ($2.50 a month each for one location, $5 for multiple locations), has no free plan, and bundles features most teams under 25 people will never touch. If you run a clinic, café, retail floor, or job site and you want a time clock your team will actually use, here’s a full, line-by-line comparison of ClockOut and When I Work: pricing, GPS, kiosk, payroll exports, and the small-team realities the marketing pages skip.

At a glance

ClockOutWhen I Work
Free planUp to 2 people, including you, forever14-day trial
Starting paid price$19 / mo for up to 5, then $3 per person$2.50 / user / month (one location), $5 (multiple)
Time clock included in entry plan✓✓
GPS + geofencing✓✓
Kiosk mode (PIN)✓✓
Open shifts & swaps✓✓
Exception inbox✓✗
Compliance rules engine✓Partial
Payroll export (ADP / Gusto / QB)✓✓
Setup time~60 seconds1-2 days typical

When I Work prices from wheniwork.com/pricing, checked October 15, 2026. Its pricing FAQ says every plan includes employee scheduling, time and attendance software, and team messaging.

Pricing: what you actually pay

Time-clock SaaS pricing is famously sneaky. Headline numbers rarely match what hits your card on day one. Here’s the full version for both products.

ClockOut pricing

  • Free: $0/mo, up to 2 people, including you. No card required.
  • Starter: $19 / month for up to 5 people, then $3 per extra person. Unlimited employees, kiosk mode, geofencing, exception inbox, PTO, alerts, timesheet approvals.
  • Pro: $39 / month for up to 5 people, then $6 per extra person. Adds payroll runs (lock + export), ADP/Gusto/QuickBooks, compliance engine, multi-location, scoped roles, API access.

When I Work pricing

  • No free plan, only a 14-day trial with no card.
  • Single location: $2.50 per user per month, with scheduling, time and attendance (GPS clock-in) and team messaging included.
  • Multiple locations: $5 per user per month. Annual billing is offered, but no annual price is published.
  • Payroll and POS integrations are in every plan. No When I Work payroll product is priced on the page; it promotes a Rippling partner offer instead.

Time clock and GPS

Both apps capture GPS on every punch and let admins draw geofences around each location. The differences are in the small moments:

  • Out-of-bounds handling. ClockOut blocks a clock-in from outside the work area and alerts admins right away, never blocks a clock-out (an off-site clock-out is recorded and reported), and lets you mark field staff geofence-exempt.
  • Offline mode. ClockOut captures clock-ins offline and syncs when connectivity returns, useful for basements, walk-in coolers, and remote job sites. When I Work is online-first.
  • Kiosk mode. Both support tablet kiosks with PIN entry. ClockOut’s kiosk runs in the browser on any tablet an admin sets up once, no MDM enrollment required.

The exception inbox (only ClockOut)

Late arrivals, missed breaks, no-shows, unapproved overtime, every shop has them. The question is whether your software catches them or buries them.

ClockOut auto-flags every exception and routes them into a single inbox managers can clear in a few minutes a day. When I Work has alerts and reports but no equivalent unified queue, you piece exceptions together from the schedule view, the time approval view, and the alerts feed.

Payroll exports

Both products export hours to ADP, Gusto, and QuickBooks. ClockOut Pro includes the workflow most owners actually want: preview hours, lock the period, export, then either send to payroll or generate a PDF for records. The export formats are ready-to-import, no spreadsheet remapping.

When I Work lists payroll integrations on every plan. It does not price a payroll product of its own; its pricing page promotes six free months of Rippling, a partner offer.

Who each tool fits best

Pick ClockOut if…

  • You have 2-500 employees and want an exception inbox and payroll-ready exports from the same tool.
  • You need geofencing, kiosk, and an exception inbox out of the box.
  • You run payroll yourself and want to lock + export in two clicks.
  • You want a free plan to actually try it without a sales call.

Pick When I Work if…

  • You’re scheduling-only and don’t need a time clock.
  • You want scheduling, a time clock and messaging at a low per-user price for one location.
  • You’re managing 100+ employees with complex labor budgeting workflows.

FAQ

Is ClockOut really free?
Yes. Up to 2 people, including you, forever, no credit card. Past two people you upgrade to Starter at $19/month for up to 5 people, then $3 per extra person.
Can I switch from When I Work without losing data?
Export your employee roster and recent timesheets as CSV from When I Work. Importing employees into ClockOut takes a couple of minutes, past timesheets stay archived in CSV.
Do both apps work on iPhone and Android?
Yes. ClockOut Time Clock by Ophy Labs is on the App Store and Google Play, and ClockOut also runs as a web app (PWA) from the browser for anyone who would rather not install anything. Offline punches work either way.
Which one handles California meal-break compliance?
ClockOut Pro includes a configurable compliance engine: daily and weekly OT thresholds, mandatory meal periods, rest breaks, max consecutive days. Violations route into the exception inbox automatically.
Keep reading
Comparisons

How Much Does Employee Scheduling Software Cost? 7 Tools Priced at 10, 25 and 50 People (2026)

Comparisons

Deputy Pricing 2026: What 10, 25 and 50 Person Teams Really Pay

Comparisons

When I Work Pricing 2026: What 10, 25 and 50 Person Teams Pay